小兒科.Parenting | 一站式育嬰.懷孕.講座.成長.健康資訊
  • 主頁
  • 大富翁
  • 博客
  • News
    • Vision and Mission
    • Privacy
  • Play
  • Doctor
  • Special Topic
    • BB發燒 >
      • Guide
      • 醫管局點評發燒
      • 為何發燒燒不停
      • BB發燒唔退點算好
      • 發燒應否食藥及應對方法
      • 判斷發燒病情嚴重要素
      • 發燒溫度表
      • Disclaimer
      • 發燒小冊子 (仁安醫院)
      • 專家話焗汗敷冰退唔到燒
  • Video Channel
    • 二十四孝
  • Link
    • 醫訊站
    • hkkids
    • 親子易點明
    • 嵐 . 手記
    • tagcloud-generator
    • Babynews 親子雜誌
    • 幼兒護理資料庫
  • E SOCIAL WORKER
  • Child Health
  • School
  • 主頁
  • 大富翁
  • 博客
  • News
    • Vision and Mission
    • Privacy
  • Play
  • Doctor
  • Special Topic
    • BB發燒 >
      • Guide
      • 醫管局點評發燒
      • 為何發燒燒不停
      • BB發燒唔退點算好
      • 發燒應否食藥及應對方法
      • 判斷發燒病情嚴重要素
      • 發燒溫度表
      • Disclaimer
      • 發燒小冊子 (仁安醫院)
      • 專家話焗汗敷冰退唔到燒
  • Video Channel
    • 二十四孝
  • Link
    • 醫訊站
    • hkkids
    • 親子易點明
    • 嵐 . 手記
    • tagcloud-generator
    • Babynews 親子雜誌
    • 幼兒護理資料庫
  • E SOCIAL WORKER
  • Child Health
  • School






劉美娟 張崇德 長子張天藍夭折案 接生醫生停牌兩年  劉聞判落淚 「BB好似俾人誤殺」

27/5/2014

0 評論

 
图片
醫委會經過12日聆訊和商議,昨日終就藝人劉美娟及張崇德夫婦長子張天藍夭折案判決。為天藍接生的婦科專科醫生蔡明欣被控七項專業失德,有四項裁定成立,判停牌24個月,判詞指蔡的專業水平遠低於香港醫生的一般水平。

至於因未及時將天藍轉送公院搶救的兒科醫生尹錦明則脫罪。劉美娟聞判後落淚指「BB好似俾人誤殺咗」,其夫則批評判刑太輕。

近八個小時的商議,張崇德及劉美娟夫婦一直在場等待。劉美娟在聞悉判決後哽咽落淚,稱聆訊證明蔡明欣有錯失導致兒子夭折,「BB好似俾人誤殺咗,感覺好難受」。她又形容可能在醫學角度未能判尹錦明罪成,但在自己心中,兩位醫生都要為事件負責。

張崇德批評判刑過輕張崇德稱,不明白為何對涉風化案的醫生被判永久釘牌,「但係人命只係咁樣(兩年)」,認為無任何事比生命更重要,對結果表示失望,但強調尊重醫委會判決。

图片
醫委會在判詞中詳細分析蔡的「四宗罪」,其中多次強調蔡明欣專業水平遠低於香港醫生的一般水平。判詞指,蔡無足夠證據支持進行羊水刺穿術,亦無足夠時間講解穿羊水帶來的風險,就為距離預產期還有20日的劉美娟刺穿羊水催生;而蔡錯誤在診所而非醫院刺穿羊水,亦無着劉美娟即時入院,亦是錯誤。

到晚上接生時,蔡使用真空吸取術的過程中有延誤及困難,增加胎兒創傷及窒息風險,卻未有安排兒科醫生在旁候命隨時急救;天藍出生後,蔡未有替天藍進行適當急救,又在天藍瀕死的情況下,容許張祟德為兒子剪臍帶及交到劉美娟手中拍攝合照。四項控罪一同執行,共判處蔡停牌24個月,刊憲後即時執行。

兒科醫生指控不成立

至於為天藍搶救的尹錦明,醫委會指,護士當日無完全按為他指示定時為天藍量血壓及匯報情況,又未有及時安排轉院,雖在臨床判斷上有失誤,但未至於構成專業失德,故裁定他一項專業失德指控不成立。

蔡明欣的辯護律師求情時,在庭上讀出多封病人家屬對蔡的致謝信,又指蔡在事發後九年來背負着自責與內疚的包袱,現時每次接生時均有一支醫生團體隨時候命,確保不會歷史重演;又指蔡於沙士期間,曾到最先爆發疫情威爾斯親王醫院的8A病房幫忙。

對於今次裁決,並無參與今次聆訊的醫委會委員蔡堅表示,醫委會在量刑時,一般會參考過往同類案例,若判刑過重,或會提高被告上訴得直機會,「如果醫委會判得過重,就會成為被告向高等法院上訴理據,法庭會睇番過往同類案例嘅判刑,或會增加成功上訴嘅機會。」

對張崇德指涉風化案醫生刑罰較重,但涉及人命卻只判停牌24個月,質疑判刑過輕。蔡堅表示,兩者性質不同,而且並非所有涉風化案的醫生都被判永久釘牌,指醫委會審訊醫生涉非禮女病人等風化案時,會考慮涉事醫生犯案原因及重犯風險。
 
委員指蔡無吸取教訓

麥列菲菲在裁決後表示,風化案件與本案性質不同,不會評論個別事件。據了解,委員認為蔡明欣於整個聆訊期間,仍堅持自己事發時的所有決定無問題,顯示她並沒有從事件中吸取教訓,故需判她即時停牌,沒有緩刑空間。至於尹錦明,委員雖認為他沒有及早將張天藍轉往公立醫院的決定「不理想」,但未致於「離晒大譜」,故判他無罪。

案情指,劉美娟05年2月18日到婦產科醫生蔡明欣產前檢查,蔡在未知會的情況下為劉進行羊胎穿刺術,更指示劉到聖德肋撒醫院待產。劉美娟一直陣痛至深夜於19日凌晨誕下天藍,當時沒有呼吸。尹錦明凌晨1點45分到達醫院搶救,其間天藍被指頭部有出血及要插喉協助呼吸,延至同日下午才轉送伊利沙伯醫院深切治療部,翌日凌晨死亡。醫委會09年接獲投訴,至13年底方正式展開聆訊。

http://hk.apple.nextmedia.com/news/art/20140526/18733063







0 評論



發表回覆。

    圖片



    Flag Counter

    按主題分

    全部
    24 Filial Piety
    Ads
    Ads For Charity
    Ads For Free
    Ads For Reference
    A Snap Shot
    Baby Activity
    Baby Animal
    Baby Community Resources
    Baby Community Resources Tuen Mun
    Baby Community Resources Tuen Mun Open Hour
    Baby Community Resources Tuen Mun Open Hour Friday
    Baby Community Resources Tuen Mun Open Hour Monday
    Baby Community Resources Tuen Mun Open Hour PH
    Baby Community Resources Tuen Mun Open Hour Saturday
    Baby Community Resources Tuen Mun Open Hour Sunday
    Baby Community Resources Tuen Mun Open Hour Thursday
    Baby Community Resources Tuen Mun Open Hour Tuesday
    Baby Community Resources Tuen Mun Open Hour Wednesday
    Baby Course
    Baby Food
    Baby Food 13 Month To 18 Month
    Baby Food 19 Month To 24 Month
    Baby Food 6 Month To 12 Month
    Baby Game
    Baby Game Ice Breaking
    Baby Health And Disease
    Baby Health Government
    Baby Music
    Baby Play
    Baby Play Place Group
    Baby Play Place Individual
    Baby Play Place Recommend
    Baby Play Place Recommend HK Central And Western
    Baby Play Place Recommend HK Islands
    Baby Play Place Recommend HK Shatin
    Baby Play Place Recommend HK South
    Baby Play Place Recommend HK Tai Po
    Baby Play Place Recommend HK Wan Chai
    Baby Play Place Recommend HK Yau Tsim Mong
    Baby Play Place Recommend HK Yuen Long
    Baby School
    Baby School Kindergarten
    Baby School Primary
    Baby Shop
    Baby Teaching
    Baby Teaching Cheuk Yu
    Charity
    Charity Donation
    Column
    Column_childfly
    Column Media
    Column Media AM730
    Column Media Apple
    Column Media EastWeek
    Column Media Headline
    Column Media Metro
    Column Media Ming Pao
    Column Media Oriental
    Column Media Sing Pao
    Column Media Sing Tao
    Column Media Skypost
    Column Media Ta Kung
    Column Media Wen Wei Po
    Column Media Yahoo
    Column Michael Leung
    Column_Others
    Column Social Worker
    Developmental Stages
    Developmental Stages Before Pregnancy
    Developmental Stages Early Childhood
    Developmental Stages Infancy
    Developmental Stages Pregnancy
    Developmental Stages Pregnancy Period Begin
    Developmental Stages Pregnancy Period Late
    Developmental Stages Pregnancy Period Mid
    Domestic Helper Matter
    Eat
    Editor Choice
    Family
    Family_Animal
    Family_Animal_Golden
    Family_Animal_Lego
    Family_Animal_MuiMui
    Family_CheukYu
    Family_CheukYu_Music
    Family_CheukYu_School
    Family_CheukYu_School_kindergarten
    Family_CheukYu_School_Kindergarten_Agnes
    Family_CheukYu_School_Kindergarten_Agnes_Admin
    Family_CheukYu_School_Kindergarten_Agnes_Learning
    Family_Dian
    Family Entertainment
    Family_Food
    Family Medical Record
    Family Medical Record Cheuk Yu
    Family Medical Record Tsz Yu
    Family_Minsin
    Family_MinsinBrother
    Family_MinsinFather
    Family_MinsinMother
    Family_Quin
    Family_QuinFather
    Family_QuinMother
    Family_TszYu
    Faq
    Faq Baby Care 0 To 6 Month
    Faq-baby-care-0-to-6-month
    Faq Baby Care 13 To 24 Month
    Faq-baby-care-13-to-24-month
    Faq Baby Care 25 To 60 Month
    Faq-baby-care-25-to-60-month
    Faq Baby Care 7 To 12 Month
    Faq-baby-care-7-to-12-month
    Faq Baby Immunization
    Faq-baby-immunization
    Faqfever
    Faq Growth And Diet 0 To 6 Month
    Faq-growth-and-diet-0-to-6-month
    Faq Growth And Diet 13 To 24 Month
    Faq-growth-and-diet-13-to-24-month
    Faq Growth And Diet 25 To 60 Month
    Faq-growth-and-diet-25-to-60-month
    Faq Growth And Diet 7 To 12 Month
    Faq-growth-and-diet-7-to-12-month
    FAQ Mother Baby
    Faq Parenting 0 To 6 Month
    Faq-parenting-0-to-6-month
    Faq Parenting 13 To 24 Month
    Faq-parenting-13-to-24-month
    Faq Parenting 25 To 60 Month
    Faq-parenting-25-to-60-month
    Faq Parenting 7 To 12 Month
    Faq-parenting-7-to-12-month
    FAQ Social Knowledge
    Fate
    Fate Zodiac
    Fate Zodiac All
    Growth Stage 0 To 1month
    Growth-stage-0-to-1month
    Kindergarten
    Kindergarten Profile
    Kindergarten Profile TM
    Materialbook
    Materialvideo
    Materialvideotakecarebb
    Materialworksheet
    Materialworksheetdiy
    News
    News Survey
    Others
    Others Baby Accident
    Othersbabymalpractice
    Others Baby Malpractice
    Others Baby Milk Powder
    Others Baby Model
    Others Baby New In Entertainment
    Others Baby News
    Others Baby News Education
    Othersbadbehavior
    Others Bad Behavior
    Others Bad Peoples
    Othersgoodbehavior
    Others Good Behavior
    Others Good Peoples
    Otherssurprise
    Others Surprise
    Others Survey
    Paediatrics
    Paediatricscentralandwestern
    Paediatrics-central-and-western
    Paediatrics-central-and-western
    Paediatricseastern
    Paediatrics-eastern
    Paediatrics-eastern
    Paediatrics-female
    Paediatrics-female
    Paediatricsislands
    Paediatrics-islands
    Paediatrics-kowloon-city
    Paediatrics-kowloon-city
    Paediatrics-kwai-tsing
    Paediatrics-kwun-tong
    Paediatrics-kwun-tong
    Paediatrics-male
    Paediatrics-male
    Paediatrics-north
    Paediatrics-sai-kung
    Paediatrics-sai-kung
    Paediatrics-sham-shui-po
    Paediatrics-sham-shui-po
    Paediatrics-sha-tin
    Paediatrics-southern
    Paediatrics-southern
    Paediatrics-tai-po
    Paediatrics-tsuen-wan
    Paediatrics-tsuen-wan
    Paediatrics-tuen-mun
    Paediatrics-tuen-mun
    Paediatrics-wan-chai
    Paediatrics-wan-chai
    Paediatrics-wong-tai-sin
    Paediatrics-wong-tai-sin
    Paediatrics-yau-tsim-mong
    Paediatrics-yau-tsim-mong
    Paediatrics-yuen-long
    Paediatrics-yuen-long
    Parenting
    Parenting Story
    Parenting-story
    Parenting Theory
    Partner And Sponsor
    Partner And Sponsor Ads
    Partner And Sponsor Blogger Event
    Partner And Sponsor Hirer
    Partner-and-sponsor-hirer
    Partner And Sponsor Hirer Watek
    Partner And Sponsor Product
    Pharmacy
    Pharmacy Central Western
    Pharmacy Eastern
    Pharmacy Islands
    Pharmacy Kowloon City
    Pharmacy Kwai Tsing
    Pharmacy Kwun Tong
    Pharmacy North
    Pharmacy Sai Kung
    Pharmacy Sham Shui Po
    Pharmacy Sha Tin
    Pharmacy Southern
    Pharmacy Tai Po
    Pharmacy Tsuen Wan
    Pharmacy Tuen Mun
    Pharmacy Wan Chai
    Pharmacy Yau Tsim Mong
    Pharmacy Yuen Long
    Positive Thinking
    Positive-thinking
    Positive Thinking Story
    Qiaohu
    Qiaohubaby
    Qiaohuselfhelp
    Qiaohusocialskill
    Seminar
    Seminar Baby Training
    Seminar-baby-training
    Seminar Before And After Pregnant
    Seminar-before-and-after-pregnant
    Seminar Pregnant
    Seminar-pregnant
    Share Internet
    Social Power
    Social-power
    Socialskill
    Social Skill
    Socialskillmotivation
    Social Skill Motivation
    Socialview
    Social View
    Trivia
    Triviapregnant
    Tweet
    Usefulcontactlist
    Useful Contact List
    Useful Smart Tips
    Usefultool
    Useful Tool
    Usefultooltravel
    Useful Tool Travel
    Useful Website Statistics
    Vaccine
    Vaccinebcg
    Vaccine Bcg
    Vaccineforbaby
    Vaccine For Baby
    Website
    Website Statistics

    按日期分

    一月 2020
    九月 2019
    七月 2019
    六月 2019
    五月 2019
    四月 2019
    三月 2019
    二月 2019
    十二月 2018
    十一月 2018
    九月 2017
    八月 2017
    七月 2017
    六月 2017
    五月 2017
    四月 2017
    三月 2017
    二月 2017
    十一月 2016
    十月 2016
    六月 2016
    十一月 2015
    十月 2015
    九月 2015
    八月 2015
    七月 2015
    六月 2015
    五月 2015
    四月 2015
    三月 2015
    二月 2015
    一月 2015
    十二月 2014
    十一月 2014
    十月 2014
    九月 2014
    八月 2014
    七月 2014
    六月 2014
    五月 2014
    四月 2014
    三月 2014
    十月 2013
    八月 2012
    五月 2011
    九月 2010
    四月 2010
    三月 2010
    九月 2009

    Flag Counter
    RSS
提供者 使用自訂式範本建立您的專屬獨特網站。